What's new

Piece will not bend to 90° RESOLVED

WillB

Member
I made this piece from an existing .dxf and instead of bending to 90° when I did a sketch bend it wants to curl up. What am I doing wrong?
 

Attachments

  • Botched shield.AD_SMP
    896.5 KB · Views: 5

DavidJ

Administrator
Staff member
It doesn't like the sketch bend not doing entirely within the sheet.

Here is one approach based on your file.
 

Attachments

  • Botched shield (mod).AD_SMP
    622.5 KB · Views: 4

HaroldL

Alibre Super User
Here is another method for bending your part. Not knowing the forming process you will be using to form this .188 thick part it may be better to cut out the mid section. The minimum flange length for this thickness may dictate the process.

Remove the center cut out from the base sketch:
Cutout Removed from Base sketch.png

Unbend and cut out center after the 1st bend:

Unbend and Cutout Center Relief.png

Add Tab after Rebending the part:

Add Tab After Rebend.png

Here's the final image:
Finished Bend.png
 

Attachments

  • Botched shield - Fix Method 2.AD_SMP
    574.5 KB · Views: 1
Last edited:

DavidJ

Administrator
Staff member
I modified your first sketch to remove the problem parts of the shape. Your bend now works.
Un-bend , then project sketch 1 to new sketch (as reference) - convert the required items to regular figures.
Cut the mid section out.
Re-bend.
Botched new cut result.jpg Botched new cut sketch.jpg Botched Re-bent.jpg Botched sketch 1.jpg
 

idslk

Alibre Super User
Also a way...Part1
create the base

upload_2020-4-17_17-43-18.png

cut a hole with the second sketch
upload_2020-4-17_17-43-31.png

pattering the hole
upload_2020-4-17_17-43-46.png

creating an oblong on the next sketch
upload_2020-4-17_17-44-14.png

cutting the oblong
upload_2020-4-17_17-44-32.png

pattering the oblong
upload_2020-4-17_17-44-45.png

mirroring the oblong and the pattern
upload_2020-4-17_17-45-1.png

create a line on the next sketch for one bend
upload_2020-4-17_17-45-31.png

bend at sketch line
upload_2020-4-17_17-45-53.png

create another sketch and bend there too, but in reverse direction
upload_2020-4-17_17-46-21.png

part 2 will follow... ("only" 10 pics per post)
 
Last edited:

idslk

Alibre Super User
part 2

ceate a new sketch to cut the strap
upload_2020-4-17_17-53-14.png

cut the strap
upload_2020-4-17_17-54-29.png

2 things to mention:
one: if you use a bend line which stops in the base material, it will create a cut relieve for you automaticaly (if activated int he bend dialog)
upload_2020-4-17_17-57-56.png

upload_2020-4-17_17-58-58.png

two: constraint your sketches.

Regards
Stefan
 
Last edited:
Top