Why different Flange Results

[wsimonton]

The two sheet metal parts are left and right sides. Alibre has created two different results where the top tab ends at the 3" radius. I do not know why. The Right Side (done first) result appears atypical which I cleaned up the arc.

The Left Side also appears atypical. One result or the other (wrong/incorrect or not) should be expected but not both.

 

[DavidJ]

You'll need to provide the missing items too - otherwise difficult to even begin to guess what you are asking about. Either add the part used in conversions, or produce a package file from the final items.

 

[wsimonton]

I know better. Here are the packages.

 

[DavidJ]

You have different settings for Bend Relief on the advanced tab of each Flange 4.

 

[Oldbelt]

Relief settings corrected. There was some "lapanderværk".
Bent.

 

[wsimonton]

That may be a partial answer, but if I delete that Top Flange and set the Advanced Parameter the same as the other as I re-create the Flange that does not create identical flanges. Maybe I set a hard parameter in earlier flanges?

 

[Oldbelt]

The flange must start exatly where the 3" round end.
I had difficulties to set the strain relief figures, I had to redo the flanges,
first the relief has to be set up in >files>properties>......
May be there is a SW failure.

 

[wsimonton]

Attached is the Complete Vent Assembly. (with Oldbelt's assistance). Thanks all.